Al-Ahram’s Version of Journalism

(Post by LB) 

Al-Ahram Weekly, in its usual shrill anti-Israel pseudo-journalistic style, ran an article this week by Khaled Amayreh entitled “Israel’s very own Guantanamos”. Without attributing its claims, and by making outrageous comparisons, Al-Ahram tries to paint a picture of a violent Israel summarily torturing Palestinian prisoners in modern-day concentration camps. 

Israeli maltreatment of Palestinian captives and political prisoners has reached unprecedented levels of brutality, according to lawyers, human rights groups and newly-released prisoners.

There are currently as many as 12,000 Palestinian detainees languishing in Israeli detention camps, many of them without charge or trial. They include hundreds of university professors, engineers, school teachers as well as religious and civic leaders, students, resistance fighters and women activists.

It is no secret that most “resistance fighters” are involved in other professions on the side-many suicide bombers are students or lawyers who decided that their professional lives needed the extra flavor that killing Jews would bring.

Two years ago, the Israeli occupation authorities abducted hundreds of democratically- elected officials, including mayors, members of local city councils, law-makers, and cabinet ministers, many associate with Hamas’s political wing.

Hamas political wing merely enables its militant wing- their arrest is a blow to their ability to harm Israel.

Israel employs a set of draconian laws, some dating back to the British mandate era, to torment Palestinian prisoners. The same laws are also used to lend a façade of legality to other harsh treatment of Palestinians, such as house demolitions, land confiscation and deportation.

All of Israel’s activities are approved by the Israeli Supreme Court, and ordinary Palestinians can challenge the IDF in court regarding any of these policies.

Normally, the harsh treatment meted out to Palestinian detainees starts in earnest with crack Israeli soldiers raiding a given Palestinian home in the quiet hours before dawn. There, the undisciplined soldiers normally ransack the house, vandalise property and furniture, smash house appliances and terrorise the entire family, before blindfolding and handcuffing their victim and dragging him away to a military truck that takes him to one of the dozens of interrogation centres all over Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories.

Crack soldiers, or undisciplined? Soldiers who take anything from a Palestinian house, even sugar for a drink, are court-martialed and disciplined. Would the nights I spent in Gazan homes during operations speaking and drinking coffee with the men of the house be considered terrorising the family? In keeping with protocol, any search of the house was done with the head of the household present at all times, and it was he who opened all closets and drawers, so that he could not accuse us of destroying or stealing anything.

Upon arrival at the interrogation centre, the detainee is instantly subjected to an array of harsh treatment techniques designed to shock him and destroy his psychological immunity. These include sleep deprivation and solitary confinement as well as sporadic beating.

Then the victim is made to go through the routine technique called shabh whereby he is forced to sit on a 25cm high stool, with his hands tied to his back. He can be kept in this extremely uncomfortable position for weeks or even months except for short periods to go to the toilet and eat.

The main purpose behind the harsh treatment is ostensibly to extract confessions from the victim. On many occasions, the victims confess to having committed fictitious violations only to escape the harsh and intolerable torture. Eventually, however, if no confessions are extracted, the detainee is sentenced to administrative detention, or open-ended captivity without being charged or tried.

Torture, which the Israeli judicial authorities euphemistically refer to as “moderate physical and psychological pressure”, is officially sanctioned by Israel’s law. Indeed, several Palestinian detainees have recently died in Israeli jails either due to torture or medical negligence. According to the Palestinian Prisoner Club, which monitors Israeli treatment of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails, 167 Palestinians have died in Israeli custody since 1967.

However, while torture was normally performed on detainees mainly in order to extract confessions, the Israeli prison authorities have been using torture for the purpose of simply tormenting and humiliating Palestinian detainees.

“Their goal is to make us suffer, to torment us, to humiliate us. They want to punish us further for our survival, for refusing to die and disappear as a people, for refusing to collapse. Perhaps they think that by tormenting us, they get the feeling that they are avenging the holocaust, at least vicariously,” said Mohamed Abu Zneid, from Dura, who was released recently from an Israeli detention camp near the Egyptian borders. “But I can say that such behaviour can only come from a sick people, a sadistic people. Otherwise, why would normal people behave this way?”

Perhaps the author would like to provide some basis for his claims from someone other than a former prisoner? This is not journalism.

“Administrative detention” which is a mere euphemism for prolonged and mostly unlawful captivity as punishment for one’s political thoughts and attitudes has become of late the modus operandi of Israeli treatment of Palestinian prisoners. Today, Israel is detaining hundreds of mostly innocent Palestinians in detention camps all over Israel, such as the notorious Kitziot concentration camp in the Negev desert.

Concentration camp? A concentration camp with visiting hours (security prisoners Sunday-Wednesday, criminal prisoners Thursday). During my basic training at a base right next to Ktziot, I spent time guarding the bunker which overlooks the prison. I was surprised to see prisoners playing soccer and volleyball, and generally milling about calmly. Much like a concentration camp. Moreover, daily I would see busloads of Palestinian family members arriving to visit their imprisoned relatives.

A few years ago, Mustafa Shawar, a detainee at Kitziot, informed this writer that on several occasions he had appealed to the Jewish military “judge” at the Treblinka-like facility to tell him why he was being incarcerated so that he wouldn’t commit the same violation again once he was released. Shawar, a senior lecturer at the University of Hebron, said the judge paid no attention to his just request. “He told me that he wouldn’t grant me the privilege of knowing why I was in jail because, as he said, the Jews are the masters and non-Jews are the slaves and the chosen people are under no moral or legal obligation to explain to the inferiors why they are being mistreated.”

Shawar is undoubtedly lying through his teeth here.

Today, Shawar is still languishing at Kitziot for the fourth successive year, not knowing why he is being tormented by a state that claims to be a “light unto nations” and the “only democracy in the Middle East”.

Shawar is not an exceptional case. He epitomises the fate of thousands of Palestinian detainees and hostages languishing in Israeli detention camps, mostly for harbouring ideas and thoughts that the Ashkenazi establishment deems too dangerous.

Interesting that he brings in the Ashkenazi comment. If one would poll Sephardi or Russians regarding those prisoners, they would find the exact same sentiments as one would among Ashkenazi Jews. I wouldn’t be surprised if non-Ashkenazi Jews would generally support harsher policies vis-a-vis Palestinians. Meretz and Labor, both left of center, are seen as ‘Ashkenazi’ parties. The defense establishment has seen many non-Ashkenazis rise to positions of influence, including former Chief-of-Staff Shaul Mofaz and former Defense Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer. The author is attempting to portray Israel as inherently racist, not only toward Arabs, but also toward its own citizens.

Similarly, Azzam Salhab, professor of comparative religion at Hebron University, has been languishing in the same desert concentration camp for eight years on vague charges such as “constituting a danger to the safety and security of Israel and the Jewish people.”

According to the Nafha Society, a human rights group defending Palestinian prisoners’ rights, the Israeli occupation authorities issue dozens of administrative detention orders per month.

Earlier, this week, the Israeli army renewed the “administrative detention” for Radi Sami Al-Asi for additional six months. Al-Asi, a journalist from the northern West Bank town of Nablus, was arrested on unspecified charges. However, when it became clear that there was no evidence indicting him, the Israeli military judge decided to sentence him to six months in jail, renewable for as long as the occupation authorities deem fit. So far, Al-Asi has spent more than 38 months in administrative detention without knowing why.

Farhat Asad, a 40-year-old father of three children from Ramallah, was sentenced to a sixth term of administrative detention on 16 June. All in all, Asad has spent more than 100 months in administrative detention.

According to Tawhid Shaaban, a prominent lawyer from East Jerusalem, some detainees have spent nine years in Israeli captivity without charge or trial. “Yes, this happens in a state that claims to be the only democracy in the Middle East.”

The so-called “death ride” is one of the most agonising and nightmarish experiences a detainee undergoes. It starts with a sudden raid of a given ward by the notorious Nahshon squad, which is specialised in repressing Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails. Then a prisoner or several prisoners are ordered to board an extremely filthy, hot and nearly hermetically sealed white vehicle, allegedly in order to appear before a judge several hundred kilometres away. The hateful vehicle would move very slowly from one prison to the other to carry additional prisoners, including dangerous Jewish criminals. The car would stop every hour for refreshment, while the inmates are sweating in the back chamber.

The nightmarish journey, which could last for 24 hours, is first and foremost meant to make the prisoners suffer as much as possible in the oven-like metal chamber where there is very little oxygen. The prisoners are barred from using toilets for close to 16 hours, and some are forced to urinate and defecate inside the lock-up car.

Saed Yassin, a human rights activist describes the “death ride” as “an intolerable and unbearable form of torture. They don’t treat you as a human being but as cattle or a piece of luggage. People are left to rot and suffer in these oven- like chambers for up to 24 hours without food, without water, and with very little oxygen. And if they want to torment a given person, he is forced to undergo this nightmare every few days.”

In addition to the death ride, the Israeli Prison Authority has been introducing additional forms of punishments, aimed at breaking the prisoner’s will. These include barring family visits for an extended period of times for the slightest and pettiest violation of outstanding instructions.

Moreover, the Israeli occupation authorities have been barring family visits for more than 900 Gazan prisoners in Israeli jails under the pretext of the 18-month harsh blockade which Israel has been imposing in Gaza. The Red Cross asked Israel on several occasions to allow Gazans to visit their beloved ones, but to no avail.

Israel recently resorted to “unorthodox tactics” to harass Palestinian prisoners, including raiding and vandalising their homes and mistreating their wives and children, imposing hefty financial fines on them, and carrying out surprise searches usually after midnight.

Last week, lawyers and newly-released prisoners reported that the Israeli Prison Authorities have naked Jewish women, probably prostitutes, harass prisoners, especially religious inmates, through sexually suggestive behaviour. A spokesman for the prison authorities refused to confirm or deny the revelation.

5 Responses to Al-Ahram’s Version of Journalism

  1. Barry Meislin says:

    Gosh, if you can’t trust Al-Ahram, whom can you trust?

  2. Zeph says:

    “Last week, lawyers and newly-released prisoners reported that the Israeli Prison Authorities have naked Jewish women, probably prostitutes, harass prisoners, especially religious inmates, through sexually suggestive behaviour.”

    Strange that a jihadist whose ultimate aim is to die for the cause which would entitle him to perpetual pleasures of fornication with 72 “virgins” and 28 pre-pubescent boys to take care of their ‘needs’would find this objectionable in real life.Moreover the implication that the naked women were Jewish is another instance of projection, wherein the evil Jew is held responsible by a patently sexually frustrated loser.

  3. Albert says:

    Another good example of Demopathia.

  4. oao says:

    wherein the evil Jew is held responsible by a patently sexually frustrated loser.

    you don’t understand: you’re not supposed to enjoy sex in this world, only in the next. suppression of any enjoyment in this world is the core mechanism in arab/muslim societies to keep people away from any ideas about a decent life in this world, such that they can accept a miserable life, be controlled and their energy channeled to jihad and death, in order to get in paradise what they don’t get here. that’s how arab oppressive regimes are so effective in keeping themselves in power.

    as to the complaints of the jailed, that’s just their usual lies to fool the infidels who believe in their victimhood.

  5. […] me. It’s like Western liberals for whom Gitmo is worse than the Gulag (or, for Amayreh, Israeli prisons are like Gitmo): they get to keep saying it. Reporting under a police state in the West Bank By TANIA TABAR Posted […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *