Israel is Isolated, Needs Sane and Steadfast Friends

This post just went up at the Telegraph, where they gave it a sensationalist title to attract readers. As the editor said, “Now let the s*** storm begin.” Sort of like Max and The Wild Things… not (check the comments – wow!)

Israel has rarely been so isolated.

Rumors are, that it’s so bad, that that stiff-necked right-wing Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu is under heavy pressure to be more placating, to calm the storm.

Of course, in so doing, Israel would be playing the role of sacrificial offering on the altar of Jihadi warfare. Contrary to the exceptionally naïve expectations of the proponents of such a conciliatory stance, a reasonable, apologetic, concessionary Israel will not appease Muslim hatred, nor calm the roiling waters of Arab anger. On the contrary, it will play directly into the hands of the Jihadis who aim at the, to us, ludicrous, goal of world domination.

And any Western country that thinks sacrificing Israel in this manner will improve the situation, rather than weakening itself profoundly in a global battle it should be winning hands down, is deluding itself. Instead of pouring water on the fires of religious war – something virtually every thoughtful Westerner considers the most dangerous and destructive of forces – they would be pouring oil on the Jihadi apocalyptic forest fire that grows with every passing year. If you’re worried about global climate warming, shouldn’t you also be worried about global Jihad warming?

Drawing by Ellen Horowitz, 2006

Israel, paradoxically, is also in a particularly strong position. Few alliances last long in this part of the world, and no sooner are reconciliations announced than they begin to fray. The very countries that, in their move to Islamism, have turned against her, have, at the same time, gutted their armies of their military professionals. Even as they strut on the international stage, making threats and demanding abject apologies, their military ability to confront Israel wanes. And of course, the Israel he’d meet would not be the wounded, defensive one with which he shadow-boxes daily. Israelis have always had more heart for fighting real wars than for constant low-grade battles with terrorists who hide behind civilians in order to gain a propaganda victory.

Indeed, the situation of the Turks is so perilous, that one (typical) conspiracy theory circulating in among them now is that Obama has been encouraging Erdogan’s intransigence so that Turkey will enter into a disastrous war with Israel and end up losing not only to them, but to their troublesome neighbors, the Kurds. Have Egyptians really believed their fantastic narrative about defeating Israel in 1973, a victory snatched from them (rather than from the Israelis) by meddlesome Westerners? Is the mob mentality in the street and in the media, so much in evidence in 1967, still capable of driving them to a war with Israel?

Behind the military weakness lies economic weaknesses. High wheat prices from drought-stricken China played a major role in both sparking the “Arab Spring” and the weakness of Arab economies (with and without oil) pose major threats to the largely dispossessed people. With problems like this, only fools and tyrants would resort to scapegoating one of the most economically successful and productive nations in the neighborhood, as a way to move forward. If the Turks continue their belligerence, their Jewish population will leave Turkey, and the unemployment rate will, according to some estimates, almost double.

Israel should, if anything, hold fast and let the Arabs and Muslims vent their impotent furor; even to challenge them. Israel should call Turkey’s morally repugnant bluff about concern for Palestinians even as it crushes its own minorities. Western human rights activists would do everyone a favor by spotlighting Turkey’s troubling record, for more than just the purpose of keeping them out of the EU. I’m quite sure the Kurds and the Greek Cypriots would much prefer Israel as a neighbor than Turkey – indeed, honest Arab inhabitants of Jerusalem, like those who would say they would move out any parts of Jerusalem given to the PA, would admit the same.

Of course such pushback might lead to war. No one in Israel wishes for war. Every soldier’s death and every dead civilian on both sides, is experienced as a national tragedy. Unfortunately, even impotent venting can lead Muslim leaders down dark tunnels that they can’t escape. The extremist street can and has propelled them into following through on their rhetorical flourishes and drum rolls. Foolish Arab leaders, fueled by false pride, will lie to each other about their capabilities, as Nasser did to the Jordanians in 1967, forcing themselves into confrontations that will cost them, the West and Israel dearly.

Of course, Israel needs help. It will need sound and sane nations and peoples who, looking at the global situation, can distinguish between firemen and arsonists, between those who show concern for both their own citizens and those of their foes, and those who willingly sacrifice their own children in order to target those of their foes. It needs outsiders who can understand that turning on one’s friends and supporting one’s enemies, reveals to any many an observer not courage, but weakness. Israel needs outsiders who understand that they are the targets of Jihad just as much as the Israelis. It does not need ideologues who can’t learn from catastrophic past mistakes.

In other words, Israel needs allies who love life, freedom, and critical intelligence. It needs them the way the Dutch needed the English as they tried to survive 80 years of vicious warfare that went on around them, and the assaults of the imperial neighbor, Spain. It needs them as the Czechs needed the Western democracies to protect them from the Nazis’ insatiable appetite. Israel needs people with discernment and a lively instinct for self-preservation.

If the West had the courage of its democratic convictions, it would make it clear to the representatives of the “Arab Spring” that the barrel of the gun only makes it possible to build democracies, but that sustaining them demands far more. It would tell the Palestinians – not just the leaders, but the people – to start doing the kinds of things that will lead to peace rather than conduct a war of ethnic cleansing masquerading a peace. It would explain to the Egyptians that scapegoating a neighbor when your own government continues to fail its people only makes the problem worse. NATO would tell the Turks to keep their ships out of the Eastern Mediterranean.

Of course that would mean that we in the democratic West begin to understand our own political history, and appreciate that democracy is not merely giving the people the vote, that military alliances don’t give a free hand to hostile partners. Without a democratic culture of fairness, tolerance, ability to self-criticize, and respect for the “other,” and can, therefore, enter into positive-sum relations with the other… all attitudes for which there is little evidence (and much counter-evidence) in current Arab political culture, one can expect those newly empowered voters to fall prey to the first demagogue who sounds the right notes.

A Westerner can say to me, “Forget it. They’ll never change. And if we criticize them, we’ll just alienate them, even provoke them. Israel is lost.” Of course, that also means we Westerners are lost, that we just delay our place on the crocodiles menu.

We have the choice between genteel suicide and mental battle.

For the Soldier who fights for Truth, calls his enemy his brother:

They fight & contend for life, & not for eternal death!

But here the Soldier strikes, & a dead corse falls at his feet,

William Blake, Jerusalem, II.41-43.

Do we have the resources for mental and moral strife, and the courage to think and act clearly?

11 Responses to Israel is Isolated, Needs Sane and Steadfast Friends

  1. 18PigsDontFly says:

    Your every word is correct. Great assessment of a sad truth. 1939 all over again, but this time we’ll fight back with all our might, so that 50 years from now our grandchildren will hear that it never happened. History will repeat itself.

  2. DavidS says:

    Richard,

    Excellent, as I have come to expect from you.

    OT, how do you pronounce “demopath”? In particular, is the “e” long as in “free” or short as in “bed”? The first sounds more natural but the second fits better with “democracy”. I find myself wanting to introduce the term into political discussions but have not for fear of settling on an incorrect pronunciation.

  3. Richard Landes says:

    short e as in bed i would guess. it’s also demotic with a short e.

  4. Annabel says:

    Exactly where is the facebook like link ?

  5. Bella Center says:

    Great article – I can’t imagine a better description of the situation.

  6. (Off-topic in a certain specific sense, but on-topic in an exceedingly important general sense):

    EXTREMELY IMPORTANT VIDEO

    Renowned Islamic Ideologue Defines Iran’s Foreign Policy
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNu_07OQspk

    Web page of another instance of the video clip:
    http://www.mrctv.org/videos/renowned-islamic-ideologue-defines-iran’s-foreign-policy

    The speech is by Hassan Rahimpour Azghadi, a member of the Supreme Council of Cultural Revolution in Iran.

    Translated by Laleh Gillani

    The website on which this video was originally hosted was seriously hacked shortly after this video was posted there.

    PLEASE BE AWARE: I think that visiting the hacked original site which hosted the video, the site lenziran.com, may compromise any computer that visits it, or may, at least, record, and provide to the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRIGC), the ip address of any computer that visits it.

  7. Fatah Official States the Real Goal of the Illegal Current Fatah-PLO-PA ‘Palestinian’-Arab-State U.N. Bid (an example of audio-video footage that Western news mass-media outlets would not show; The political leadership of Israel must get their act together and start to act like normal human beings and verbally defend their nation like normal human beings and communicate the factual history and current reality of the situation to the world; The survival of the nation of the Jewish people is at stake)

    Fatah Central Committee Member Abbas Zaki Calls Netanyahu, Lieberman, and Obama “Scumbags” and Says: “The Greater Goal Cannot Be Accomplished in One Go”, Al-Jazeera TV Arabic (Qatar) – September 23, 2011
    http://www.memritv.org/clip/en/3130.htm

    Transcript:

    Abbas Zaki: “The settlement should be based upon the borders of June 4, 1967. When we say that the settlement should be based upon these borders, President [Abbas] understands, we understand, and everybody knows that the greater goal cannot be accomplished in one go.

    If Israel withdraws from Jerusalem, evacuates the 650,000 settlers, and dismantles the wall – what will become of Israel? It will come to an end.

    [...]

    Who is nervous, upset, and angry now? Netanyahu, Lieberman, and Obama… All those scumbags. Why even get into this? We should be happy to see Israel upset.

    [...]

    If we say that we want to wipe Israel out… C’mon, it’s too difficult. It’s not [acceptable] policy to say so. Don’t say these things to the world. Keep it to yourself.

    I want the resolutions that everybody agrees upon. I say to the world, to the Quartet, and to America: You promised, and you turned out to be liars.

    [...]

    —-

    Israel – A Brief Summary of the History of the Situation
    http://danielbielak.blogspot.com/2011/03/israel-brief-summary-of-history-of_17.html

    Why and How the West Is, with Lies, Vilifying Israel
    http://danielbielak.blogspot.com/2011/03/why-west-is-vilifying-israel-excerpts.html

  8. Cynic says:

    Just came across this blog post commenting on Charles Enderlin’s blog post for anyone interested in the continuing saga of a France 2 reporter:
    Charles Enderlin : l’indécence faite règle !

  9. The YouTube channel palwatch ( http://www.youtube.com/user/palwatch ), which is the YouTube channel of Palestinian Media Watch ( palwatch.org ), which is an organization that observes, and translates into English, and posts, with English subtitles, content of the television media of the Fatah-PLO-PalestinianAuthority and Hamas television stations, has been terminated. Fatah-PLO-PalestinianAuthority and Hamas, on their television stations, state, in Arabic, their intentions to annihilate Israel, and broadcast racist genocidally anti-Jewish propaganda. Palestinian Media Watch presents, with English subtitles, that programming broadcasted by Fatah-PLO-PalestinianAuthority and Hamas. Palestinian Media Watch endeavors to present, to the world, that programming broadcasted by Fatah-PLO-PalestinianAuthority and Hamas. The YouTube channel palwatch ( http://www.youtube.com/user/palwatch ) of Palestinian Media Watch ( palwatch.org ) had several hundred video clips of the television media of the Fatah-PLO-PalestinianAuthority and Hamas television stations.

    Now, navigating to the YouTube channel palwatch ( http://www.youtube.com/user/palwatch ) results in there not being displayed the YouTube channel palwatch, but, rather, instead, results in there being displayed a page which contains the following message:

    This account has been terminated due to repeated or severe violations of our Community Guidelines and/or claims of copyright infringement.

    I suspect that the cause of the YouTube channel of Palestinian Media Watch being terminated was a campaign of false flagging by ‘Palestinian’ Arab activists, and/or Muslim Arab non-’Palestinian’-Arab activists, and/or Muslim non-Arab activists, and/or Western Leftist so-called “Anti-Zionist”/”Pro-Palestinian” activists (Western Leftist totalitarian anti-Jewish racists).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>